Weather

Sunday, May 20, 2012

The Trial of Socrates

Phil Burpee, Columnist
Phil Burpee

     In 399 B.C., the Athenian philosopher Socrates was tried and sentenced to death. The trumped-up charges laid against him were remarkable for their ambiguity – viz. ‘corrupting the youth, and impiety’. In further detail his accusers referred to two now bleakly famous specific manifestations of ‘impiousness’: - "failing to acknowledge the gods that the city acknowledges" and "introducing new deities." To say that the charges were spurious is an understatement, for his true crime had been to challenge the ‘knowledge’ and ‘wisdom’ of the powers of the day – to buzz about without cease as a pestering gadfly calling into question the lofty, self-ascribed credentials of the great and good of his day. He was found duly guilty and subsequently sentenced to imbibe a lethal concoction of hemlock, which, according to historical myth, he did, and was thusly martyred to the very foundation-stone of Western philosophical tradition. For he believed that to question was paramount to the human condition, and that to pursue a “life without examination” was to pursue a life not worth living. Or as the old bumper sticker would have it – ‘Question Authority’.


     The trial itself has been extensively documented and commented upon from Plato down through I.F. Stone, and is considered to be as relevant today as it was then. But Socrates was always uncomfortable with the label ‘wise’, and would typically offer the disclaimer that the only way in which he was wiser than other men was that he was conscious of his own ignorance, while they were not. And so the Socratic method of philosophical, moral or intellectual discourse is to convince the other person that what he thought he knew, he did not in fact know at all – and thereby hopefully to establish fundamental insight. This is done through a series of challenges, postulates and pointedly-crafted riddles which say that if ‘a’ implies ‘b’, and ‘b’ is predicated on the assumption ‘c’, which is itself demonstrably false or just patently absurd, then ‘a’ itself must also be false. This style if inquiry has come to underlay what we now know as the empirical method, the absolute kernel of all true and verifiable science. It is called Reason. We have inherited this through the Enlightenment, with much thanks to the French Revolution, in direct line from Socrates. It also survives as the essential method of examination and cross-examination now so well known in the British and American courtroom. We here in Canada similarly subscribe under the basic tenets of the Common Law. In French you don't say ‘You are right,’ but rather ‘Vous avez raison’ – you have reason. How sublime.

     But the elevation of opinion, myth, folk tale, scripture, political dogma, or outright lie into irrefutable fact is a pernicious bugbear in the evolution of human consciousness. Consider the efficacious technique know as Papal Infallibility, which was a mainstay of the Roman Catholic church for several centuries, and was integral to the carrying out of the Inquisition. Or think of the ruined lives that accrued from the pogrom initiated by Senator Joe McCarthy in the U.S. under the guise of the Red Scare of the 1950s. Mere innuendo and scraps of circumstantial perception were quickly and irreversibly rendered as damnable truth, and there was no appetite to see reason prevail. Knowledge itself can also fall prey to such excesses. And then we must beware all those who would, by so acting, propose a “life without examination.”

“The claim to possess exclusive truth is a vain one. And, as with other markets, the ones in ideas and information are damaged by distortion and don’t respond well to clumsy ad hoc manipulation.” Christopher Hitchens

     In my day we used to call them the Brain Police. These are the purveyors of ‘convenient truths’ – or perhaps more accurately, ‘truths of convenience’. They will use any available method to propagate apparent indisputable facts which serve the particular agenda of their bosses or power bloc. It is commonly called propaganda, and has been with us for thousands of years. Examples are legion, but one of the most famous and durable is the concerted and methodical vilification and de-humanization of some ‘other’ in order to make possible the prospect of war. Because the prospect of killing other human beings does not come spontaneously to sane folk, but is an insanity that must be woven into place through orchestrated displays of the prospective enemy’s diminished claim to ‘humanness’. For it is one thing to bring to account through violence the despots, murderers and madmen who sometimes infest and appropriate civil society, but it is quite another to enter into the wholesale slaughter of the common folk, which became the accepted norm of the Twentieth Century with all its firestorms, carpet-bombings and mass, mechanical depredations of entire populations. So it is to poison minds.

     The assault on truth and reason continues today. Pronouncements of certitude pop up like rain-fed mushrooms at every turn. Preachers admonish the hapless to follow the One True Way or suffer the miseries eternal. Politicians bludgeon our intelligence with blinkered, self-serving blather. Capitalists assure us that the suffering of the many in favour of the few is an essential paradigm of the human condition. Nationalists rail against the fecklessness and moral lassitude of those who do not blindly wave the flag. Creationists decry the fruits of scientific examination, even as they lay claim to its tools in pursuit of their particular, narrow orthodoxy. Demagogues whittle away any reality that does not suit their immediate purpose, which is to prevail over others. In the hands of the unscrupulous, the glistening gold of truth quickly devolves into base lead - a perverse alchemy that afflicts the hopes and dreams of this world.

     Look around. Turn off your iPhone for five minutes. Let your head clear out. In the words of the Bard - "Give every man thine ear, but few thy voice." It is not enough to merely listen but rather to hear, to borrow the lovely phrase from 1 Kings 19 of the Old Testament, "...a still small voice." But, of course, that voice is far more ancient than any fabricated deity of the human flock. It is the unassailable fact of things - not for sale, not for breaking down, not for capricious usage, and certainly not for owning. It is, after all, in the nature of the wind to blow.

     A colleague of mine, a man of integrity and conviction and evolutionary zeal, prides himself on being a ‘corruptor of youth’. By this he means to corrupt them with art and music and learning and a questioning mind and a freedom of spirit and a willingness to love and a yearning after Truth. He is a pariah in the larger community which rather chooses to anoint its youth with prejudice and fearfulness and a craving after ignorance and slavery to congealed ideas and belief for belief's sake and kowtowing to the gods of rote and limiting their horizons and clamoring after petty reward - the sad automatons of a superficial society. For the "life without examination" is indeed not worth living - exactly because that is not living at all, but merely surviving - the life of the brute.

     The Trial of Socrates is still under way. The old gadfly is, thankfully, still amongst us. And we are still drumming up ever more fantastical accusations against him, and against those who would question prevailing received wisdoms - those 'wisdoms' which have been fabricated to suit the passing agendas of the material world. Free-thinkers, environmentalists, social revolutionaries, atheists, iconoclasts, slaughterers of sacred cows, artists, those who speak truth to power, those who speak with the clarity of the child, those who are simply brave enough to claim their own ignorance as a starting point for learning - these are the targets against whom the accusations "corrupting the youth, and impiety" are hurled.

     The barbarians are forever at the gates - those who would return us to the darkness. Only a fearlessness of spirit and an abiding hunger to know will carry us through. Such are the arrows we loose from the walls of the city. As John Keats would have had it in his 'Ode on a Grecian Urn': -

'Beauty is truth, truth beauty,' -that is all ye know on earth, and all ye need to know."


Phil Burpee
May 19, 2012

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thanks for taking the time to comment. Comments are moderated before being published. Please be civil.

Infinite Scroll